Oct 28, 2008

Food Television: A Recipe for Entertainment and Weight Gain?

What could be better than eating and watching television at the same time? Watching television that revolves around food and eating! Food Network along with other select television networks have figured out the recipe for success; give people entertainment while feeding their appetite for food. As mentioned in an earlier post, the Nielsen rating statistics have shown that The Next Food Network Star brought in very high ratings. People are really taking to food oriented programming with open arms. Although the ratings are positive, food television oriented networks have been facing a bit of scrutiny about their programming, specifically Food Network. For those not familiar it is a station that caters to food lovers. Shows are aimed towards specific audiences that really enjoy the cuisine, the host and sometimes both. Chefs and cooks include: Ina Garten, Bobby Flay, Paula Deen, Rachael Ray, Tyler Florence, Guy Fieri, Giada De Laurentis, Ellie Kreiger, Alton Brown, Sandra Lee and many others. The types of cuisine include everything under the sun; American, Italian, South West, Asian and much more.

What could be giving Food Network a bad reputation with some people? Articles from the Richmond Times and well known food blog, Noshtopia have raised the question, “Does watching Food Network making people obese?” Bonnie Taub-Dix, spokesperson for the American Diatetic Association said, “watching the wrong cooking shows can lead to unintentional overeating”. At this time in America health is becoming a serious issue, specifically when it comes to what people are eating. According to U.S. Surgeon General Richard Carmona, obesity kills more people in America per year than AIDS, cancer, and all accidents combined.

Since the launch of Food Network, people are getting many of their ideas about meals from their favorite shows. Food Network’s cook Paula Deen prepared a menu of French toast, a cheese sauce, hash brown casserole and a hot mocha float for dessert. Although that may sound like the best thing in the world, the calorie total was 2,881. That is more than what a normal intake for an entire day would be. The claim about this type of menu with these high fat and calorie recipes is that since these are the recipes they air, it is the show’s fault that its viewers are becoming obese. Food Networks test kitchen director, Kathy Alford, disagrees with the accusations that programs like this are making people obese stating, “People are looking at this as entertainment, and it is giving people a large group of things to choose from. It's a starting point for people to make their own decisions. We know people will be turned on by one recipe on a show, and not do all the recipes.”

If the decision is made to sit down to watch a show on Southern Style cooking, the obvious ingredient will be a lot of butter, which translates to a lot of fat. One would think it is common sense that eating this style of cuisine every day, even every other day, would not be healthy. Even Southern style cook, Paula Deen was quoted saying, “ I don’t eat my own cooking everyday! My lord, I’d be wider than a table if I ate biscuits and gravy every day.”

Does this put a responsibility on what should be programmed? One way to look at it would be to say, “no.” People have a responsibility to use portion control and pay attention to what they eat. It is a personal choice to focus on the shows that have high fat and calorie recipes while putting shows with hosts like Ellie Krieger (a dietician who aims for healthy living and eating) on the back burner. Another way to look at the programming is to focus on the recipes but understand that many substitutions can be made. For example, if one of the hosts makes fried chicken is it just as easy to look up a low calorie fried chicken using corn flakes and baking rather than using flour and deep-frying. Cooking, in the end, is about creativity anyway. On the other hand, nutrition is so important that many food companies are beginning to take an oath for healthier living. What does this have to do with food television programming? Everything. These networks run on paid advertising. If these advertisers are headed toward healthy living, will they force Food Network to healthier programming by threatening to pull their advertising slots? It is very possible. If this is the case it could stir up the argument that food television could be making people obese.

Although advertising tends to drive a lot of television programming due to product placement, sponsorship and basic commercials, it is highly unlikely Paula Deen and the rest of the Food Network family will be going anywhere. The bottom line is that people are responsible for their own actions. If a recipe makes a McDonald’s Big Mac meal look like a salad, it might not be the best thing to eat on a regular basis. The bottom line is that there is a lot to learn from chefs and the true responsibility is in the entertainment of the food loving community. As long as the right choices are made everyone will be able to enjoy Paula Deen adding another stick of butter.

Oct 14, 2008

The Search for the Right Ingredients: Best Foodie Sites

Due to the focus of The Right Ingredients, finding web resources can be a bit difficult. Most foodie sites tend to discuss recipes and restaurants while leaving out other issues that are still food related. Finding sites that discuss what is happening in food entertainment are few and far between. Luckily searching for sites that discuss food education tend to come around more often due to the health and nutrition movement happening all over the country. After an extensive weeklong exploration of the web, I was able to gather twenty Internet based sites that tend to have information relevant to the focus of The Right Ingredients. This post will be an observation and honest appraisal of each of the twenty sites acquired and will be based upon the Webby Awards and IMSA criteria for blogs. These guidelines are used in order to help separate the sites with facts from sites with just opinions. For more information, these two criteria sites are linked. All of the sites discussed can be found in the linkroll as well.

The first is the most influential site, the one that started the food craze, Food Network. The Food Network site (see below) is based upon the Scripps television network station and contains a plethora of information from recipes (from the newly acquired Recipezaar.com) to each show, to bios on all of the chefs and hosts of the show. They have recently redesigned the site and it flows beautifully. One flaw that could be improved is the color design of the main page; items tend to get lost amongst the white background. An item that could be added is a newsreel including things happening in the food world. Food Network happens to have two sister sites, Food Network Canada and FLN or Fine Living Network. FLN is a very well laid out site, very inviting in the color scheme. This site contains information on food, wine and entertainment aspects of food as well as housing Iron Chef Japan. Food Network Canada tends to have different information than the US site, but stays along the same lines. Next is Bon Appetit Magazine’s site, a great site with a lot of pertinent information. The magazine itself is not just about recipes but delves into what is happening in the food world. The site is well put together and does not need to improve on anything at the moment. Another site along the same lines is Gourmet Magazine's site. This site has a layout that is exactly what I tend to look for, an area for food politics, food blogs, etc. It definitely has a recipe area but again offers up more than just great dishes. A site that is found is association with these sites is Epicurious.com. This site houses many cooking articles and foodie related items. It is a great place to find new and exciting food information. The final television site that is important in the food world is Bravo TV. This isn’t necessarily a good source of information for the food world however it contains the show Top Chef; a show that has become one of the most viewed shows on television.

When searching for blogs specifically, a few were found that made their way to the top of the list. Food Buzz is very helpful site in conducting a search. Food Buzz is a food publisher site that basically certifies good foodie blogs, recipes and sites. The site has great colors, easy to read, just needs better organization and structural work. Some of the following blogs are Food Buzz certified and some aren’t, still, I find they are all quite helpful. One blog, Food Network Addict might be viewed as a gossip column to most but in reality is a source of news in the food world. Somehow this site manages to get information on what is happening in food television before anyone else. The site needs a bit of a revamping, it still looks amateur and the writing states facts but definitely has a bit of sarcasm thrown in. Next is Food Network Musings, another site that discusses what is happening in food television, food world and with the occasional recipes. This site reads a bit more like a newspaper column than most and has a very distinct layout. One thing I would change is where the linkroll and site information is placed. It happens to be on the left side, which draws my attention before any of the articles. Nonetheless, it is a great site. The next, Food Network Blog, not a very noteworthy site, however it helped me find something very specific which is why it is included. The site needs to be updated both structurally as well as content. Next, Super Chef Blog, (see right) is a great example of a food blog, a site for all things food. It is very well structured with incredible content to go along with it. So far, this is probably the best food blog site that I have come across. The only thing that could be added would be a border to each section to make it a bit more compartmentalized. The last of the mega blogs is The Amateur Gourmet. The creator of this blog has written a book as well as continues to post recipes, reviews and just foodie related topics on his site. The site is well thought out and visually pleasing. It tends to be a huge discussion area in the food world as comments are constantly being posted to the site.

There are three sites that are great sources of information as well, The New York Times, The LA Times and CNET. The two newspaper sites are laid out like newspapers would be, with food and wine sections. They are very informative and have easy ways of searching. CNET is a technical website, somewhat broad, however when it comes to video games and recent technologies it is one of the first sites to post. Occasionally my blog enters a techie type area, and this is where I end up. The last set of sites found mostly deal with government, food regulations, food marketing and children’s health. These sites aren’t necessarily the most visually appealing but their content is top notch, specifically because they set the national standards. When needing to research facts and figures, these are the best places to find them: The Federal Trade Commission, Nutrition.gov, Food Marketing Institute and one blog that deals with this subject nature, What’s In Store.

In all the time spent searching these were definitely the best sites, it is very exciting to see how Food Related Entertainment and Education have become a main course in the lives of people throughout the world.

Sep 30, 2008

Nutrition and Marketing: What Is Right For Children?

Last week I brought the current topic of video gaming for foodies to the table. I am absolutely fascinated with the way food has grown into such a huge market for entertainment. Video games are just one avenue through which food is becoming a main course for people of all ages. While sitting and thinking about the food video games, an associated topic came to mind. There have always been discussions about how kids playing video games and watching television prevents exercising and eating well. I started to wonder how marketing makes a difference when it comes to what kids are eating. This week I chose to comb through the blogosphere in hopes of finding a lot on my topic of choice, food and food marketing to kids (see picture to the left). This happens to be a somewhat controversial topic in the blogosphere. The first blog I came across “What’s In Store”, published by Dr. Susan Finn, a nutrition professional who has spent a large amount of her career trying to build productive partnerships to make better choices when it comes to nutrition. The post that I found entitled “Food Marketing to Children and Adolescents”, discussed how in October 2008, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) conducted a survey on food marketing to youth and called on the companies to “adopt and adhere to meaningful, nutrition-based standards for marketing their products to children under 12.” In this blog she offers the information and research from the FTC as well as acknowledges that 13 of the largest food and beverage companies have adopted the initiative but that it is going to take much more. The second blog I found was entitled, “Restaurant Kids’ Meals Pack Adult Sized Calories”, published by CalorieLab.com’s Robert S. Wieder in the Calorie Counter News Section. This post discusses the nutritional information from chain restaurants, how it compares to the daily caloric intake standards for children and what they are doing to improve the situation (see picture to the right). I chose to comment on these posts in hopes that I might get a response about how long it will take to get restaurants and marketing techniques more effective regulations when it comes to youth nutrition. I offered up my comments on each blog. They can be found by clicking on the links as well as below.

“What’s In Store” – My Response:

I would like to thank you for taking the time to write a post on this subject matter, as well as your blog. I find it very interesting and highly educational. It makes me feel good to know that there are people in the world that devote their time to such a worthy cause. I am glad that you included links to a marketing workshops agenda. I came across the statement, “Some food companies have also modified their packaging to encourage portion control and make nutritious foods more convenient for parents and more appealing to children.” I found this to be true specifically from walking around markets and observing the products. Yes, it is a step in the right direction. The problem I find with this marketing technique is even though the packaging is portion controlled; companies still haven’t tackled the fact that many people will continue to eat more than one package. The truth is if you ask people about their daily caloric intake, most have no idea. Every product is required to have a nutrition label but most of the time people tend to look at the fat content and assume that if it is low in fat, it is okay. Do you think it would be a smart idea for marketing as a whole to involve the daily nutritional information? For example, if companies sell 100-calorie packs of cookies, require a marketing campaign with other companies to show how their products can fulfill the requirements for daily percentage values and caloric intake? Are there campaigns to have that sort of marketing and advertising aimed at adults with children, implemented on a national level?

I absolutely enjoyed reading your blog, specifically this post. However, I would’ve liked to read more about your personal opinions regarding the subject matter. The fact that you are a nutritional professional would bring a different angle to the marketing story. I am positive that you can provide innovative thoughts on the best way to reach the public regarding this very important matter.


“Restaurant Kids’ Meals Pack Adult Sized Calories” – My response:

Thank so much for providing information on this subject. The comment “American Kids get their one third of their caloric intake from restaurant meals” was incredibly thought provoking. After spending a lot of time recently in restaurants on a very strict diet (based solely on calories) it is easy to see how people, especially children are becoming obese. It is shocking to see at most of the restaurants the average caloric value was over twice what it should be for one main meal. If that number stayed consistent for 2-3 meals per day, does that mean kids will be consuming approximately 3,000 calories? Do you feel like it has a lot to do with marketing? That it might be a problem if restaurants are advertising their establishments as a prime source of nutrition and daily intake for kids? It is mentioned that the restaurant association is putting the blame on parents stating that nutrition starts at home and that kids are not getting an adequate amount of exercise. Even if a child is exercising every day, consuming 830 calories for meal is definitely not considered healthy. I feel that Subway has taken a step in the right direction offering apples, milk and yogurt to children as well as adults for meals. The problem is if a child gets a sub loaded with cheese and mayo, it will exceed their intake for that meal. What additional steps are being taken with restaurants that are at least publishing their foods caloric values?

I am highly disappointed in restaurants for their lack of concern when it comes to nutrition for children. Your article is a great way to create awareness on these highly important topics. I would love to see correspondence from some of these establishments with explanations of how they feel their products are healthy as well as more of your opinion as a journalist on this matter.

Sep 23, 2008

Serve It Up, Interactive Style: Video Gaming for Foodies

In the early 1980’s arcade games were in full force and, believe it or not, games related to food were the hottest items on the menu. The game that started it all may not have seemed like a food game, but after taking a closer look, it is easy to see that Pac-Man was a hungry little guy. The chomping Pac-Man would run around trying to eat everything in site: ghosts, pellets and fruit. This may not be something that seems too appetizing, but still food related. Not long after Pac-Man, came the arcade game Burgertime, creating burgers with tiny creepy walking pickles and fried eggs. Burgertime may not necessarily be the most exciting and complex of video games but it was fun nonetheless. Fast forward to 2003 and Diner Dash, where the object of the game is to wait on tables, from PC satisfies the hunger for food video games that were neglected for the most part through the 1990’s. Still, nothing specifically about the process of cooking was created, until 2006 when Nintendo released a game for its DS system called Cooking Mama. With Cooking Mama, chopping, stirring, boiling and sautéing are simulated thanks to the touch screen of the DS. Yet even with the Nintendo DS there were still ingredients missing, but thanks to Nintendo another game system that has gone above and beyond was released on the market in 2006. Enter the Nintendo Wii, a system that enables the player to physically play a game by simulating movements in order to accomplish tasks. After speaking to former food critic and professional chef, Marsha Carden, I was led to question whether or not these games might be missing the most important ingredient, by which I mean taste.

Food Entertainment has become more of a need than a supplement in a number of lives across the country. People are taking pride in cooking and making the right choices when choosing foods for daily meals. According to Nielsen statistics, The Next Food Network Star was in the top ten most viewed programs in July 2008. What does this say about the market? They are hungry for something besides typical dramas or comedies when it comes to television programming. It seems to be the same for the video game market as well. Nintendo has been working diligently to get new food games to the public and so far they are succeeding. Besides the Cooking Mama series Nintendo has released Order Up, a game about buying a diner and winning the title of a competition that will put the it on the map. This seems to be what gamers are calling “charming and fun” but lack the components of a two or more player competition many find to be necessary. Another interesting addition to the cooking video game market is Nintendo’s Cooking Guide: Can’t Decide What To Eat? This is more of an instructional interactive cookbook that gives you the ability to search from about two hundred recipes through different search techniques such as by time, main ingredient and difficulty.

In October 2008, Nintendo along with Black Lantern Studios will be releasing the video game version of the highly rated television show, Iron Chef America, to be called Iron Chef America: Supreme Cuisine. This game will feature real voices and movements from Masaharu Morimoto, Cat Cora, Mario Batali, Alton Brown and the Chairman (Mark Dacasco). Not only will players be able to compete with the Iron Chefs, they will also be able to play as an Iron Chef, which is something many foodies dream of while they are sitting at work. From the screenshots shown on the Iron Chef America game site, it looks as though the player will be able to perform many cooking techniques that are very necessary in the preparation of food in Iron Chef America’s Kitchen Stadium. Not only are the choices in foods and secret ingredients going to impress the player but the graphics are phenomenal. As far as cooking video games go, it looks as though Iron Chef America: Supreme Cuisine is going to “reign supreme.”


The introduction of interactive cooking is revolutionary in the video game market. People of all ages who wish to cook are now able to get in a virtual kitchen without the worry of handling real kitchen utensils and equipment. Virtual cooking games are a way of reaching a whole new generation by creating an appreciation that may have been overlooked in the past. Culinary gaming is definitely a step forward in the world of cooking. When preparing a meal, the cook’s main concern usually is not whether they have the proper chop or the most creative plating technique but rather if their guests will like what they are eating or not. Obviously taste and smell are still the two senses that the video game designers have not been able to incorporate into games. Even without these two key ingredients, the majority of the reviews are still positive. Reviews, however, come from amateur cooks or gamers who simply enjoy the novelty. A certified chef might argue that without the two key ingredients of taste and smell, these games are an incomplete reflection of the true art of cooking.

Although cooking style games are spicing up the video game market this is still a relatively new technology, so this means there aren’t yet a lot of documented opinions. My thought is that while the general public will most likely adore the games, foodies, chefs and food connoisseurs will be left with a bad taste in their mouths. Coming from the perspective of a foodie, I tend to agree with the chefs and food connoisseurs. The best part of cooking is the taste and the smell of the food. However, I do see how this is a great step forward for the gaming community and will hopefully inspire a new generation of cooks and chefs.
 
Add to Technorati Favorites
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.